In 1955, Dr. Axel Nogard, a retired dentist, owner of Butternut Springs, and nature-lover, wanted to sell 40 acres of his land near Valparaiso, Indiana, to Girl Scouts. The camping committee of Girl Scouts of Chicago saw this property as a perfect troop camping site with woods, hills, a creek, and several lakes that fed from a number of springs. Ultimately, Dr. Nogard sold his entire 129 acres for $70,000, with negotiations completed in March 1956. An additional 65 and 110 surrounding acres were added in 1963 and 1964.
The house at the camp, built in 1918, became known as Spring House; with renovations inside, one room became the Infirmary. An A-frame building became the Pack Out Kitchen (replaced in 1963), where summer campers came to get food supplies for their units, carrying the provisions in large baskets that fit on their backs.
Another small building became known as Treasure Hut for its nature center (long gone now). By the time of the camp dedication on June 11, 1957, three of the five planned unit houses had been completed. The Wieboldt Foundation’s large donation supplied the name for that cabin unit. A new caretaker’s home was ready in 1959, with a garage workshop in 1966. By this time, more construction had brought sewers, water, and electrical lines into the camp, as well as a pay phone!
During the early years, swimming and boating took place in the largest lake, which had been drained, dredged, and provided with a beach. Eventually, a pool was built and dedicated on July 18, 1978, paid for by the Girl Scouts, selling over 300,000 boxes of cookies! A new pool and pool house now replace it.
Butternut Springs, with its butternut tree near mineral springs that provided healing powers, is steeped in Native American lore. Trail Tree’s path leads up to the unit house and passes the great deformed oak tree that marks a chief’s grave. Legend has it that ill and injured Native Americans drank the spring water and were able to ride away on their horses; thus, the saddle formation was created by tying down the sapling oak. Additionally, the land was used by Native Americans for burials, with 36 identified mounds, underscoring the camp’s rich cultural heritage.
Other units had names related to their locations: Hickory Unit was named for the hickory trees; Running Water for the creeks that flow around it; Rock Road for the gravel roads that ran by it; and Primitive on the top of the hill where one might find arrowheads.
In 1965, Mr. Roger Anderson and his wife Sis (a longtime Girl Scout leader, troop consultant, and advisor to Senior Girl Scouts) became the caretakers. The lake near the Ranger/Caretaker’s house was renamed Anderson Lake in 1984 to honor their dedication to Girl Scouts and 15 years overseeing Camp Butternut Springs. This continued the focus on nature and the outdoors that Dr. Nogard nurtured.
Butternut Springs continued to grow. Beckoning Woods (Becky) was named in a contest because the woods are beckoning to campers, and McCormick Lodge (Mac), named for the McCormick family’s donation, was built in 1975. A Gathering Place, program and troop center, and Trading Post now reside in place of Rocky Road. On the hill in the primitive area, Friendship Cabin was built with more units, and the outdoor spaces have also grown. The oval track and fitness field has areas for soccer, softball, volleyball, archery, a sledding hill, and a zip line. A high ropes course and a climbing wall add to the challenges. Four marked trails provide year-round adventures. To end an active day, a site for Girl Scout campfires awaits with the peace and quiet (and s’mores) of the night.